← BackSee all toolsPursuit Qualification Scorer: a Go/No-Go for BidsWorking demo · sample data · shows a method I used, not a real event
Qualification · pursue, shape or pass

Pursuit Qualification Scorer

Eight criteria, one score and three outcomes. A way to decide whether an opportunity deserves capture time before the proposal hours are spent. The criteria follow a well-known sales checklist for qualifying deals (MEDDPICC), adapted for government bids.

I built this method for qualifying government pursuits at a public-sector staffing and consulting firm. The weights, thresholds and example here are fictional.

The question

Should we spend capture time on this?

Every opportunity feels promising on the first call. This is the scorecard that makes the decision explicit: eight criteria, one score out of 100, three outcomes, and two hard stops that no score can override. Score the example, or load a preset.

52/ 100
Shape

Not yet. Spend a bounded amount of effort closing the top gaps, then re-score within two weeks.

Metrics: size of the need weight 12

How many roles, for how long, and what does delay cost the customer?

2 Defined roles and a start date

Scoring guide
  1. 0 Unknown
  2. 1 A handful of roles, no timeline
  3. 2 Defined roles and a start date
  4. 3 Quantified roles, a budget per role and a cost of delay
Economic buyer weight 15

Do we know who owns the money, and have we met them?

1 Identified, not met

Scoring guide
  1. 0 Not identified
  2. 1 Identified, not met
  3. 2 Met once
  4. 3 Met, and they own the budget
Decision criteria weight 12

Do we know how the answer will be judged, and do we score well?

2 Stated by the customer

Scoring guide
  1. 0 Unknown
  2. 1 Assumed
  3. 2 Stated by the customer
  4. 3 Stated, and we score well against them
Decision process weight 10

Do we know the steps, dates and people between now and award?

2 Mapped with dates

Scoring guide
  1. 0 Unknown
  2. 1 Partly mapped
  3. 2 Mapped with dates
  4. 3 Mapped, and we know where we are in it
Paper process: vehicle and compliance weight 18

Is there a contract path we can use, and do we meet the eligibility and certification requirements?

1 Vehicle unclear

Scoring guide
  1. 0 No path to the contract vehicle
  2. 1 Vehicle unclear
  3. 2 Vehicle known, gaps listed
  4. 3 Vehicle in hand; certifications and eligibility confirmed
Identified pain weight 13

Is the problem specific, costly and urgent?

2 Specific

Scoring guide
  1. 0 None stated
  2. 1 Generic
  3. 2 Specific
  4. 3 Specific, costly and urgent
Champion weight 10

Is there someone inside who wants us to win and will coach us?

2 An advocate

Scoring guide
  1. 0 None
  2. 1 A friendly contact
  3. 2 An advocate
  4. 3 An advocate with influence who coaches us
Competition weight 10

Do we know the field and have a reason to win?

1 Field unknown

Scoring guide
  1. 0 Entrenched incumbent
  2. 1 Field unknown
  3. 2 Field known; we differentiate on one axis
  4. 3 Field known; clear advantage or a sole-source path

Biggest gaps to close

  • Paper process: Settle the vehicle and compliance question first. Without a path, nothing else matters.
  • Economic buyer: Ask your champion for the introduction. Prepare one question the buyer can only answer by committing.

Hard stops

  • No hard stops triggered.

Illustrative weights and thresholds. In practice they are tuned against the outcomes of past pursuits. Without JavaScript the criteria and the default example still read in full.

The three outcomes

Pursue, shape or pass.

70 and above

Pursue

Real need, reachable buyer, a path to the contract. Capture resources are committed and a decision date is set.

45 to 69

Shape

Promising but incomplete. A time-boxed plan closes the top two gaps; the pursuit is re-scored, not forgotten.

Under 45

Pass

Declining is a decision, and it protects the team. The reason is logged and the relationship is kept.

How it is used

A scorecard is only useful if it runs on a rhythm.

Also on this page

Related tools folded into this page. Each opens in place; tap Close when done.

Step 2: Bid Alone, Team Up or Pass?Five questions decide whether to bid as the lead, partner with another firm, support a lead firm or pass, and the tree shows which rule made the call.Open section

This section opens in the online version. It has its own offline file in the ZIP: prime-vs-sub-teaming-tree-offline.html.

Where to Look for BidsFive kinds of buyer, a demand heat map and a way to turn a contract award into a list of roles to pursue.Open section

This section opens in the online version.

More in Revenue & Growth

See all tools