← BackSee all toolsPlatform Evaluation ScorecardWorking demo · sample data · shows a method I used, not a real event
Vendor selection · weighted decision model

Platform Evaluation Scorecard

A weighted decision matrix for choosing a ticketing platform across 14 criteria — with adjustable importance weights so leadership can pressure-test whether the winner changes when priorities change.

How it works. Each criterion is scored 1–5 per platform by the evaluation team; leadership sets the importance weight. Drag the weights to see whether the recommendation is robust or sensitive to priorities. Pricing is intentionally excluded until vendor quotes are available.
CriterionImportance (0–5)Platform APlatform BPlatform C
Automation & workflows
Flexible automations that blend support and product workflows
5445
Integration ecosystem
Plays well with the identity suite and BI tooling
5534
SLA & reporting
Native SLA engine and escalation tiers
5254
Client portal & branding
Most polished customer-facing experience
4433
Technician ease of use
4354
Client ease of use
5443
Reporting / BI export
Quality of API for BI tools
4454
Onboarding & migration
Import/export complexity
3443
AI & automation potential
4454
Asset & device management
Handled internally today
3335
Multi-organization management
4344
API & webhook quality
5454
Knowledge base & SOP integration
5344
Long-term fit
Scales with product-support needs
5354

Scores are illustrative. The real evaluation also recorded written rationale per score and an explicit “pricing pending” caveat.

Also on this page

Related tools folded into this page. Each opens in place; tap Close when done.

Keep, Pilot or Replace an AutomationThe same weighted scoring applied to the tool stack: what to keep, what to trial and what to replace, with a governed migration plan.Open section

This section opens in the online version. It has its own offline file in the ZIP: automation-keep-or-replace-offline.html.

Review a SupplierA prospective partner scored on value and readiness, separating what to pursue now from what to hold.Open section

This section opens in the online version.

More in Data, Reporting & Decision Support

See all tools